For as long as I can remember, since starting to make my own scratch cakes, yellow cake has been my nemesis. I admit that I am pretty hard to please when it comes to a yellow cake because I always imagine a taste like a southern butter pound cake and a mouth feel like a fluffy yellow oil-based…(gasp) box cake. All of the chemicals in a box cake really make for a fluffy, delicious, tender soft crumb and I was determined to recreate that mouth feel sans the chemicals.
You might ask, why not just use cake flour? This, of course would solve a lot of problems but I can’t really market my cakes as natural and European style by using a heavily bleached processed product, and personally I loathe the taste and smell of cakes that are made with cake flour. I can actually taste the bleach and the chemicals and it really takes away from that rich buttery flavor. I knew there had to be a way around this.
I can’t tell you how many recipes I have tested, because I prefer to stay in denial rather than admit how much money and ingredients I have thrown away due to my obsession with making the perfect yellow cake. I can tell you though, that if a method of making yellow cakes existed, I have tested it. I’ve tried hot milk cakes, mud cakes, meringue type cakes, pound cakes, reverse creaming cakes, simple yellow cakes, white cakes turned into yellow cakes…you get the idea. There were Australian recipes, European recipes, French recipes and countless numbers of American recipes and none of them have scored all 5 stars for me.
Here’s how I rate each recipe and thus award stars:
1 star for taste - I’m looking for a rich buttery taste here with a hint of vanilla
1 star for texture – Soft, velvety mouth feel with a tender, light crumb with no crusty edges – I do NOT want my cake to feel like a muffin in your mouth
1 star for moistness - The cake needs to stay moist without drying out when it cools
1 star for chemicals – The lack of them, I want the cake to work with all-purpose flour and NOT bleached cake flour
1 star for stackablity – I want the cake to be light, velvety and fluffy, but I don’t want it to crumble and fall apart and I need it to hold up to rich buttercreams, heavy ganache, and multi-level, multi-tiered fondant covered cakes
Whew! That’s a tall order. And anyone who bakes scratch cakes will tell you that this list is pretty close to impossible to achieve ALL five of those stars at once. But have faith because it can be done folks, read on…
At first I considered using oil rather than butter to achieve the moistness and lightness, but not surprisingly, it lacked the butter flavor and left an oily residue in your mouth…FAIL!
I got the texture perfect and got rid of the chemical taste by using self-rising flour instead of bleached cake flour, but then realized that the self-rising flour was also bleached…FAIL!
I tried using a combination of hot milk and butter tempered to a specific temperature (hot milk cake) then added to the A/P flour. The cake smelled and tasted seriously buttery and rich and delicious but the crumb, when cooled, was too coarse and resembled a muffin rather than cake…FAIL!
I tried an A/P flour corn starch combination and the cake sunk in the middle…FAIL!
I have produced many cakes that taste perfect with a wonderful fluffy texture and buttery taste but every single one, and I am not exaggerating here, has sunk in the last 2-3 minutes of cooking. Were talking anywhere from “looks like someone sat on the cake” to deep meteor craters sent down from the evil cake failing gods. Can I blame the altitude and climate of Colorado for this sad disaster of: mix, cross fingers and say a prayer, bake, rise, sink, fail, scrape into trash? Probably. But that wont stop me from trying though and quite possibly becoming the best scraper-of-cake-into-the-trash-bin-while-the-cake-pan-is-burning-your-hand chick…ever!
The good news for you though, is that my past failure can now be your yellow butter vanilla cake saving grace. Why? Because I would say that if a cake recipe works and is awarded all five of those stars AND is baked in the unforgiving location of the rocky mountains, you can pretty much bet it will work for you too.
Why this recipe works: This recipe actually happened by accident. It was a busy day making both my go-to yellow buttermilk cake and my double chocolate sour cream cake. I accidentally added the sour cream for my chocolate cake into my yellow buttermilk cake and realized what I had done half way through baking. To my delight, the cake was the most luscious, buttery, fluffy and moist yellow cake I had ever baked. After a couple of small tweaks to the recipe, it was absolute perfection. The combination of both sour cream and buttermilk is what I believe to be the culprit…that, and the addition of potato starch. Potato starch can be used as a thickener in place of corn starch. It is also used a lot in gluten free baking to soften the crumb of otherwise dense and tough baked goods. The potato starch in this recipe works wonders and lightens up the all-purpose flour and produces a tender soft crumb like cake flour would. You can find potato starch in most grocery stores in the baking isle (Bob’s Red Mill) or natural food stores.
Note: I use weight measurements when baking, but I have tested this recipe with the volume amounts below and it was just as perfect If you don’t want to use the potato starch or you cant find it, you can use 3 ½ cups of regular bleached all-purpose flour instead.
( It’s a Miracle!) Yellow Butter Vanilla Cake
(Makes 3-9 inch rounds, one half sheet cake, or 3 dozen cupcakes. Recipe can be scaled in half if necessary)
339 g (1 ½ cups) unsalted butter, softened
452 g (2 ¼ cups) superfine or bakers sugar: I use organic cane sugar ground fine in a food processor – buy it here
5 large eggs @ room temp (use the highest quality eggs you can find. Preferably organic pasture raised)
1 Tablespoon pure vanilla extract
2 teaspoons sweet sherry cooking wine or Madeira – buy it here
416 g (3 ¼ cups) unbleached all-purpose flour: I use organic unbleached Einkorn flour – buy it here
24 g (3 Tablespoons) potato starch – buy it here
1 Tablespoon aluminum-free (non GMO) baking powder – buy it here
½ teaspoon baking soda
3/4 teaspoon kosher salt
296 ml (1 ¼ cups) buttermilk
8 ounces (1 cup) sour cream
Note: If using regular bleached flour or cake flour, omit the potato starch and use 448 g (3 1/2 cups) of flour.
Turn oven on to 350 degrees. Place oven rack in the middle of the oven.
Generously butter the pans then place parchment paper (cut to fit) on the bottom of the pan only. BTW: I am making a 6 inch, 3 layer cake for this blog which will leave lots of batter left over for cupcakes. For most of my cakes, I bake in 3 inch high cake pans and tort them (cut them into layers) after they are cooled and semi-frozen. For this recipe, however, you want the shortest amount of baking time to keep the cake moist and tender. For this reason, I bake this cake in single layers, which means more pans to butter and parchment. In the end, the extra work is definitely worth it. Alternatively, you can also bake this recipe in a half sheet pan and then cut your layers out of that (works well for smaller cakes), and then you are only dealing with one pan.
To cut the parchment paper to fit: Place the cake pan on top of a sheet of parchment paper, using a pencil draw around the edge of the pan. Cut out with scissors and place the paper pencil side down into the buttered pan. Set the pan(s) aside.
Have all of your ingredients ready. Remove the sour cream and buttermilk from the fridge and set on counter to warm up just a bit. Make sure your butter is room temperature and measure out amounts on a scale or by volume.
It’s very important that your eggs be room temperature so they don’t turn the butter cold when incorporated and produce lumps (which can cause large air bubbles in your cake). I never take my eggs out to warm up before hand however. Instead, I remove my eggs cold from the fridge, place the eggs into a bowl and cover with warm water while I prepare the batter. By the time I need them, they are room temp.
In your mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat the butter and the sugar together.
TLB Tip: Don’t rush this important step. I usually mix for a minimum of 5 minutes. Start on low speed until the butter and sugar are well combined then crank the mixing speed up to medium high and let it go until light in color and very fluffy. You want to incorporate a lot of air here so that the texture of the cake will be light and airy. If you rush this, the cake will be dense and thick.
While the butter is beating, sift together the flour, potato starch, baking powder and baking soda into a bowl. Add the kosher salt and set aside.
Add the sherry to the butter and sugar mixture and mix well, scraping the bowl as often as needed.
Next, add in the eggs one at a time, scraping the bowl often.
TLB Tip: When a recipe says to add the eggs one at a time, it really means one at a time. Again, don’t rush this. Add the egg and mix completely until no streaks of the egg remain. Stop the mixer and scrape the bowl and paddle down after each addition of egg. The eggs need their time to emulsify so they can build stability in your cake when baked.
Add the flour mixture to butter mixture on low speed alternating with the buttermilk mixture (buttermilk + vanilla), starting and ending with flour.
TLB Tip: Now is the time to keep the mixer on low speed and never any higher. We want to keep the gluten levels as low as possible to keep the cake tender. Once the flour hits the butter, mix only until half way incorporated before adding the buttermilk. You will still see flour that hasn’t mixed in yet and that is okay because we will render that in the next step.
Remove the bowl from the mixer and scrape off any residual batter/flour from the paddle. Scrape down the bowl, add the sour cream and fold/stir in the sour cream by hand.
Keep mixing and folding until sour cream is completely mixed in and batter is nice and smooth, making sure to reach down to the bottom of the bowl with the rubber spatula and fold upwards.
Divide batter evenly among pans, lightly tap pans once against the counter to dislodge any large air bubbles and settle the batter.
Bake the cakes until the tops spring back just slightly when touched in the center and a toothpick comes out clean. About 20-25 minutes depending on your oven and cake size. Start testing for doneness 3 minutes before timer beeps and watch the cakes carefully. Do not overbake.
TLB Tip: When you can smell the delicious buttery aroma of these cakes baking, it’s time to start testing for doneness. Cakes will let you know, by smell, when they are done cooking. They might not always be done, and you can put them back in for a few more minutes and watch them carefully. But this way, you will not over bake them.
Cool cakes in their pans for 20 min (set a timer). After 20 minutes, cakes will still be warm to the touch, which is what you want.
Place a layer of plastic wrap over the cake still in the pan…
Place a cooling rack over the cake…
With one hand on the bottom of the cake pan and the other on top of the cooling rack, carefully invert the cake over to its bottom…
Carefully lift off the cake pan, and gently peel off the parchment paper…
Wrap the cake with the over hanging plastic wrap and then one more layer of plastic, being careful not to wrap too tight and cause the edges of the cake to be misshapen. Place cakes in the freezer while you clean up and prepare the frosting (this will make the cakes easier to trim, level, tort or shape).
If you will be leaving the cakes in the freezer for an extended time, wrap the cakes again in tin foil over the plastic wrap to prevent freezer burn. Cakes can be kept frozen for up to 4 months.
BTW: This recipe also makes fantastic cupcakes…
Light, fluffy, moist, buttery, tender…delicious!